Psychiatrist vs Addictions Specialist, Whose Opinion Is More Legally Binding?
Question by : Psychiatrist vs addictions specialist, whose opinion is more legally binding?
Addiction specialist or psychiatrist. Whose evaluation is more legally binding.?
My employer sent me to see a psychiatrist to see how severe my depression was and how it would effect my return to work. The psychiatrist said that I should be fine seeing a good therapist, not necessarily a psychiatrist for 6 months to a year and then he would reevaluate me to see about my fitness to return to work. My employer then sent me to see an addictions specialist who surmised that I was a drug addict needing 45 days of detox and then when I do go back to work I have to do a urine test every two days. I have to admit that because I am not at work at present I do indulge in the ganja on occasion which is why I tested positive with the addictions specialist. I am by no means a chronic user and I have not been at work since Feb of last year. I DO NOT NEED DETOX!
When I asked the employer why they will not consider the psychiatrists opinion their answer to me was “He’s not an addictions specialist”. The “addictions specialist” is actually a sports injury doctor with a special counseling course in addiction. Is it true that his opinion can override that of a psychiatrist?
Best answer:
Answer by keiko
They probably have to pay less to have you complete the addictions program. They sound like a good company, paying for any evaluation at all. If you are depressed, smoking pot will make you more depressed. You’ve been out of work for over a year. What have you done to help yourself? I ask this having gotten help for depression myself. I don’;t know how much warning you had about seeing an addictions specialist (M.D.), but if you smoked pot after you knew you would be going you could be sabotaging yourself. Think about why.
Add your own answer in the comments!
ARC Addiction Recovery Centre – My Rehab – [email protected] – www.myrehab.co.za ARC is an upmarket, private treatment facility for those that might be suffering from the effects of addiction or alcoholism. ARC is committed to providing practical, ethical, and effective treatment initiatives to persons with addiction problems. ARC believes that by encouraging individuals to explore their previously damaging patterns of behaviour, within a healing and safe therapeutic environment, they are empowered to make positive and creative life choices. Thus they are enabled to lead productive and responsible lives free from active addiction. ARC provides a safe and caring environment for those affected by addiction, drug and alcohol dependency. Our primary focus as a professional team of addiction specialists is to assist and equip individuals with the knowledge and tools required to overcome the horrors of addiction and substance abuse. With a view to healing the body, mind and soul, our residents are given the foundation needed for on-going, wholesome fulfilment and successful living. Our professional team of addiction specialists and medical practitioners are on call 24 hours a day to assist with the detox and recovery process. Our staff compliment includes 24 hour nursing staff and substance abuse councillors, Trauma councillors, Psychologists, Psychiatrists and Group therapists. Our Recovery Coaches have, themselves, endured the suffering of active addiction but are now, at the very least, 3 years free of active …